As I have mentioned in previous posts on the matter of the recent rash of youthful suicides due to homophobic bullying, many efforts are taking place across the nation to address this matter. Today, October 20, 2010, has been declared “Spirit Day” in honor of these youths, and people have been encouraged to wear purple in solidarity and for awareness of the issue.
I support this measure, but I personally believe people need to do more than just wear purple and show solidarity.
Dan Savage and many other celebrities and everyday LGBTQI individual have taken part in the “It Gets Better” project, making video statements of encouragement for those who are enduring bullying in school and telling them that things will improve, and that high school sucks for everyone. A lot of other people in my wider circles of association lately have been sharing their own stories of having been bullied in school, or at home, or in various other areas of their life and history. It is heart-wrenching to read these things, and the overall message of encouragement is a good thing, and I’m in support of it happening.
However, I have not taken part in the project, and I don’t plan to, because of two primary reasons:
1) I feel as though I would be lying if I said “It Gets Better” to teenagers who are undergoing homophobic bullying, because I can’t assure that such would be the case. I was not out in high school, and the last major homophobic bullying I underwent was in middle school; that one incident left me so upset that I retreated from social activities altogether in high school, and never gave bullies any opportunity to say or do anything to me…and it was miserable. When I was in college, and was finally able to come out, I was at one of the most liberal colleges for LGBTQI issues in the world, and I had more homophobic incidents against me than I did in all of high school. I then went to a graduate school where a friend I made in the first few weeks of my attendance was getting death-threats in the aftermath of Matthew Shepard’s slaying. I’ve had some of the most disgusting hate-filled e-mails and attempted demeanings against me in my life as a result of doing blogs like this and being available as a resource on the internet for queer spirituality. I cannot in good conscience say “It Gets Better” for everyone, because it doesn’t necessarily–some places and environments will never be better if the current trends continue; and no matter where you end up, or how much pride you end up having, or how good your circle of friends and community support happens to be (and mine is both great and essential to my continued sanity!), there are always going to be people who think they can knock you down for whatever reason based on issues of gender identity and sexual orientation.
2) Which leads me to the second point: “it” doesn’t get better; you just learn to put up with it more, and as you grow stronger in your own sense of self and identity, it bothers you less that other people think these things, say these things, and could potentially threaten you with physical violence and worse (as happened recently in New Jersey to several people)…but, you push through it and you don’t let them frighten you or bother you or dissuade you from living your life the way you want to live it. Every time I step into an LGBTQI event, or a march, or a gathering, it is possible some homophobe with serious insecurities and some religiously-inspired foolish notions may come in and decide to attack me or my friends. I hope it doesn’t happen, but I prepare for the contingency that it might. And as far as I’m concerned, they can bring it all they want–they will not get me without a damn good fight.
So, yes, one hopes that it does get better, but I cannot assure that it will for everyone or that such is the case everywhere in the world. Giving the message to teenagers that you just have to put up with it and tough it out (and that one is possibly deficient if one doesn’t feel up to it or can’t do it) is not a good thing, in my estimation–it seems like blaming the victim to me, and I am totally against that.
What can one do, then? I have two suggestions. Given that this is a religion and spirituality blog, and one specifically devoted to a particular form of queer theology, my answers are religious/spiritual in nature.
1) One of the cornerstones of my Antinoan practice is the “Prayer Against Persecution.” It can be found in The Phillupic Hymns, but I will give it in a separate entry in a few moments as well. It is a prayer that is said at most of our public rituals; it is the prayer that an aspiring Mystes Antínoou says before undergoing the Mysteries of Antinous; it is a prayer that has been incredibly effective in achieving direct results of feeling strengthened and more peaceful whenever I have used it. If you are interested in Antinous, and would like to do the prayer, you are absolutely free to do so.
2) There is also a spell I have recently written that should be effective in, if nothing else strengthening one’s resolve and one’s own fortitude in the face of homophobic bullying; and, hopefully, it will also address some of the problem of homophobic bullying at its very root–dominant religious ideologies that suggest it is okay to demean, persecute, or even kill LGBTQI people. I will give that in a separate entry here in a moment.
I also might explain some of the theologies and ideas behind each of these practices in a future post, but most importantly, I want to make these spiritual tools available for people to use if they are faced with homophobia. They may give you more strength and peace to carry on despite the difficulties; they may give you more of a sense of what sort of difficulties we face when confronting these issues, and to name them–and by naming them, to have power to overcome their influences rather than being terrorized by them. It is what I am able to do right now that doesn’t require major institutional changes or the ability to fund large and expensive educational programs or shelters for at-risk youths. But, in their own little way, perhaps saying this prayer and doing this spell will help to change the world, if done assiduously and with devotion.
May Antinous make it so!
[...] Against Persecution As I said in my last post, one tool I suggest that people who are facing homophobia can use is the Antinoan “Prayer [...]
By: Prayer Against Persecution « Aedicula Antinoi: A Small Shrine of Antinous on October 20, 2010
at 12:58 am
[...] I said in the Spirit Day post previously, here is another tool I would like to make available to those who are enduring [...]
By: Spell Against Homophobia « Aedicula Antinoi: A Small Shrine of Antinous on October 20, 2010
at 1:33 am
May he indeed.
This is kind of a similar sentiment when I was writing my own stuff. Bullying will never stop. Never. “It” is such a mercurial thing, really. We need to have options available, tools, weapons to fight and defend ourselves and endure. Snuffing it out entirely just isn’t realistic. Someone will always come up with a reason. Always. And this is my own bitter experience speaking.
By: mythicanine on October 20, 2010
at 6:38 am
I’m certainly with you on that. My own experience likewise tells me the same. While I love the effort on the part of folks like Dan Savage, Ellen DeGeneres, and so forth, they’re feckin’ big stars, and generally don’t have to work in hostile environments, or live in neighborhoods that might not be fully accepting just because they have the economic viabililty to not do so. So, for them, I’m sure things are much better now than they were in high school and college. For many of us, though, we don’t have the privilege to insulate ourselves from these things quite as easily; or, for various other reasons, we have things about us that make us less mainstream. Pagan homophobia is still allowed, for example, and still occurs, despite paganism being a supposedly non-homophobic religion, etc.
In any case, you know what it’s like, you live this reality every day…
By: aediculaantinoi on October 20, 2010
at 10:30 am
[...] their profiles purple, some LGBTQ Pagans, like author and academic P. Sufenas Virius Lupus, are questioning how useful the day, and the message of “it gets better” really are. “Which leads me to the second point: “it” doesn’t get better; you just learn to put up [...]
By: The Wild Hunt » Quick Notes: Separation of Church and State, Sedona, and Spirit Day on October 20, 2010
at 12:07 pm
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Ari Shmary R. Kolman and Amber Clark, Erynn Laurie. Erynn Laurie said: "it gets better"? wearing purple isn't enough. do something about the bullying. change the system. #spiritday http://bit.ly/9R5iVU [...]
By: Tweets that mention Spirit Day: MAKE IT BETTER… « Aedicula Antinoi: A Small Shrine of Antinous -- Topsy.com on October 20, 2010
at 1:01 pm
This is what I wrote on the topic this morning:
http://www.thorncoyle.com/musings/?p=641
By: T. Thorn Coyle on October 20, 2010
at 1:58 pm
Excellent! Thank you for sharing the link!
I’m glad to see that many people found it a bit inadequate just to wear purple in solidarity. (I’m honestly not sure I own any purple garments that are meant to be seen by people in public!) There are ways that we can battle this ignorance, and there are ways we can defend ourselves; and, being totally honest about where it comes from is an important step, which many people are starting to do, so that’s a good sign as well.
By: aediculaantinoi on October 20, 2010
at 4:20 pm
[...] as it concerns prevention of suicide for gender/sexual nonconformists, a subject very important to [...]
By: Riddle of the Underworld: A Trans Memoir from 1921 « Aedicula Antinoi: A Small Shrine of Antinous on October 27, 2010
at 8:08 pm
[...] orientations in an environment that is often safer and more accepting than it was twenty years ago (though it is not without its problems still). But, I hold out great hope that things will continue to improve–maybe not in every way, [...]
By: Natalis Antinoi MCM « Aedicula Antinoi: A Small Shrine of Antinous on November 27, 2010
at 1:37 am
[...] But, on to not-as-depressing topics! Dver recently posted on her blog about the evolution of particular devotional relationships to deities, and the post is quite excellent and I suggest you read it in full. My response in the comments there included a reference to my post last week on failure, but also to the phenomenon of “dark night” spirituality, given some of its most vivid expression by the Carmelite St. John of the Cross, but also found in such texts as the ancient Egyptian Berlin Papyrus 3024, translated in Bika Reed’s Rebel in the Soul: A Dialogue Between Doubt and Mystical Knowledge, which I highly recommend. (The latter also touches on the issue of suicide, which makes it all the more valuable, particularly in the present context, given my concerns over this issue in relation to queer youths in particular.) [...]
By: Doubt and Mysticism… « Aedicula Antinoi: A Small Shrine of Antinous on January 20, 2011
at 9:00 pm
[...] I’ve been a skeptic about the “It Gets Better” Project for a while now, as many of you may know. It’s not that I don’t think it’s not useful, it’s [...]
By: A Miscellany of Matters… « Aedicula Antinoi: A Small Shrine of Antinous on March 31, 2011
at 7:34 pm
[...] take the first term in the subject line above first, today is Spirit Day. This occasion was innovated last year in response to the large number of queer youth suicides in the summer and early autumn of 2010 due [...]
By: Dies Spiritus et Sancti « Aedicula Antinoi: A Small Shrine of Antinous on October 20, 2011
at 5:04 pm